Skip to content

Life and Interwebs

Menu
  • Blogs That Feed
  • Guilds & Clans
  • PRESENTS
  • About
  • Writers Resting in Paradise
Menu

Flex Builds Ruining Immersion?

Posted on May 6, 2014 by Isey

I am starting to feel that flexibility on my characters is hurting immersion. I am very flip-floppy on this subject so please help!

In movies and high fantasy typically a hero is “good at one thing”. Legolas has short swords/daggers but really, he uses his bow. And he is famous for it.

Luke Skywalker has a lightsaber, and uses that primarily.

There are many examples of this. Characters are identified by the way they look and the weapons they use almost as much as their personality and grander quest they are on.

I loved sword/torch in GW2 for Guardian – but I had to swap out another weapon mid rotation to maximize my DPS rotation. This just felt silly. My Guardian looked awesome with a torch and sword, press 6 buttons, swap to 2 handed sword, swap back. You don’t see that very often in movies. At least, not at the level of repetition required to get from level 6 to level 8 in a MMO.

WildStar, I fear, has the exact opposite problem. Everyone in the same class has the same weapon (essentially). It may look a little different, but Stalkers use claws, Warriors use 2H swords, Spellslingers dual wield pistols (and on). There is no room for customization except the look of the weapon. You can’t be a Warrior that uses claws.

I feel these things challenges role playing and makes other issues harder. I am assuming these are built in to solve animation and other technical issues.

I still like multiple spec options in gaming, but complete changes is just too much in my opinion (right down to skills in between pulls). There is no commitment to any sort of build or play style. My character is master of fire! and ice! and lightning! and earth! and swords and shields and staves and… and.. and.. (you get the picture.) If you are truly the proficient in all, aren’t you also the master of none? Don’t we want to feel heroic? Why can’t I fill a “role” using whatever weapons and/or look that I want? I feel as though the lack of this ruins the story potential. If I want to make myself a tank that has huge armor and a giant shield, I should be able to do that – regardless of if I want to dps or tank.

Specialization was more consistent for character building. I don’t want to go back to the old days where a healer just healed, and a tank just tanked. What I would like to see is the flexibility for us to create our own character and build them the way we want them to look (appearance wise), with the functionality of what we need them to perform. I know both WildStar and GW2 (among others) do this well with costume features, but that typically doesn’t work with weapons (the most defining feature). This does work in World of Warcraft (cross weapon transmog) if the attack animation is the same.

As I say this, I am reminded that perhaps roles are the issue. There are no tanks, healers, or DPS in Lord of The Rings. They just fight.

Then again, perhaps this thought line is just a portion of the lack of fluff that is missing in the engagement of the new MMO crop.

 

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email

Like this:

Like Loading...

2 thoughts on “Flex Builds Ruining Immersion?”

  1. Brian 'Psychochild' Green says:
    May 8, 2014 at 3:15 am

    Flexble builds are my favorite builds in MMOs. In WoW, I had a Feral Druid in TBC that could do cat DPS and offtank as a bear when needed. I wasn’t the top DPS nor could I main tank most stuff, but I was flexible and capable in multiple roles. I loved that character, and I was disappointed as WoW worked to separate out the two roles more and more.

    That aside, I don’t think it’s flex builds causing your problem. It sounds like your complaint is more about doing things that make no sense. A Guardian should be able to use a sword/torch or a 2H sword, but feeling like you need to swap to maximize your DPS rotation, especially just for a single attack, makes little sense in terms of genre tropes. I think the problem here is that since GW2 gives you so few abilities for your weapons, you end up waiting for cooldowns. I prefer systems where you have to make a choice about what abilities you should use at that point. Then again, I’ve never been one to have a strict rotation of abilities, either.

    My thoughts.

    Loading...
    Reply
  2. Isey says:
    May 8, 2014 at 9:30 am

    Psychochild to the rescue! Was definitely having a hard time putting my finger on it and you definitely helped explain part of it. Its tough to argue for ‘realism’ in a fantasy setting to begin with, but you are right – when it goes outside of the norms of fantasy even, that gets tough on the believability.

    I still think there is more to it and I am still sorting through it. I think part of it has to do with the iconic nature of fantasy heroes. If Legolas stopped using a bow and only used an axe it would feel wrong. Perhaps it isn’t just that, but being “forced” to do that to be effective that is iresome. Or, because of the huge nature of the current flexibility that you don’t get the opportunity to become known for that one thing!

    Again, I am not sure why I am struggling with what it is exactly – which is why I wrote it down and threw it out there in the first place – I think I am overcomplicating things but your comment is helping me figure it out =)

    Loading...
    Reply

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. Asmiroth on NHL PlayoffsMay 6, 2025

    Can't believe I missed this post for a week! While not a fan of this particular bracket system, there's so…

  2. Isey on Exploring HOH2: A Fun Roguelike ExperienceApril 29, 2025

    I am with you on meta progression. It's what makes it fun for me, at least. Even failing miserably typically…

  3. Naithin on Exploring HOH2: A Fun Roguelike ExperienceFebruary 16, 2025

    I've played some of the earlier titles in this series so HoH2 has definitely been on my radar, just haven't…

  4. Naithin on The Beginning Of the End : A Look BackFebruary 16, 2025

    Belated response, but yay! And as I think the comment section here has already demonstrated, pluralising 'reader' would not have…

  5. QUEST August, 2008 on I Has BlogFebruary 6, 2025

    […] In my introductory post I explained why I was going to blog (same reasons as everyone else) why I…

  • MapleStory previews Dave the Diver crossover event and new mastery nodes coming July 16
    Source: Massively Overpowered Published on 47 minutes ago By Chris Neal
  • Sapphire & Steel (1979-1982)
    Source: Contains Moderate Peril Published on 3 hours ago By Roger Edwards
  • The Road to Alliance Tournament XXI
    Source: The Ancient Gaming Noob Published on 7 hours ago By Wilhelm Arcturus
  • Exposing the Video Game Journalism Ecosystem: How the Press, Pageantry, and Community Sites Betrayed the Game
    Source: Wolfshead Online Published on 11 hours ago By Wolfshead
  • Your Long Hot Summer Starts Right Here
    Source: Inventory Full Published on 11 hours ago By Bhagpuss
  • GPT: Polishing a Phrase Till It Sings – Not a Joyride
    Source: Why I Game Published on 16 hours ago By Jeromai
  • Song of the Month: Olivia Rodrigo, Good 4 U
    Source: Superior Realities Published on 1 day ago By Tyler F.M. Edwards
  • Blaugust in Another Castle
    Source: Tales of the Aggronaut Published on 1 day ago By Belghast
  • LOTRO: Where’s your head, dude?
    Source: Bio Break Published on 1 day ago By Syp
  • FOMO Got Me: Dune: Awakening
    Source: Dragonchasers Published on 5 days ago By Nimgimli
  • Heads of State and The Accountant 2
    Source: Joseph Skyrim Published on 5 days ago By Joseph Skyrim
  • Time to Loot Journal: June 2025
    Source: Time to Loot Published on 7 days ago By Naithin
  • Shut up and take my money…what do you mean, “No”?
    Source: MailValtar Published on 11 days ago By Mailvaltar
  • Satisfactory – Tier 5 Redux
    Source: Leo's Life Published on 19 days ago By Asmiroth
  • Stars Reach doesn’t look like you remember
    Source: Dr Raph Koster Published on 22 days ago By Raph Koster
  • Next Fest and Quantum Witch
    Source: Welshtroll Published on 26 days ago
  • Everything's A Scam
    Source: Broken Toys Published on 1 month ago By Scott Jennings
  • The Great WelpSquadTV Twitch Highlight Migration
    Source: I'm Not Squishy Published on 2 months ago By Kluwes
  • Book Review: A Song of Legends Lost by M.H. Ayinde
    Source: Dragons and Whimsy Published on 3 months ago By Jaedia
  • My Pathfinder 2E Beginner Box improvements
    Source: Gaming SF Published on 3 months ago By Telwyn
  • Daily Ramble for March 10 2025
    Source: Beyond Tannhauser Gate Published on 4 months ago By Rambling Redshirt
  • Placeholders Placed
    Source: The Last Chapter Published on 4 months ago By atherne
  • A Tale of Three Dusts
    Source: Tish Tosh Tesh Published on 5 months ago By Tesh
  • Videogame Radio and Soundtrack Spotlight
    Source: MMO Gypsy Published on 6 months ago By Syl
  • Superior self-hosted music streaming without Spotify
    Source: Psy-Q's Brain Dump Published on 6 months ago
  • Real People
    Source: Kill Ten Rats Published on 7 months ago By Ethic
  • Modern SWTOR Part II: the game in 2024
    Source: Yeebo Fernbottom Published on 9 months ago By Yeebo
  • Jackpot
    Source: A**holes Watching Movies Published on 10 months ago By Jay
  • Blaugust 2024: The End of a Journey and the Start of Something More
    Source: A Hobbits Journey Published on 10 months ago By Detached
  • Repetition is the Key
    Source: I Have Touched the Sky Published on 1 year ago By rowanblaze
  • Big List Of 100 Fantasy Side Quests
    Source: Kitty Kitty Boom Boom Published on 2 years ago By Silverangel
  • Why It’s Been Quiet Around Here
    Source: Aywren Published on 3 years ago By Aywren Sojourner
  • CMON's Rising Sun
    Source: Null Signifier Published on 3 years ago By Duke of O
  • And yet another minute…
    Source: Nomadic Gamers Published on 3 years ago By pkudude99
  • The 7th Hour
    Source: Me Vs. Myself and I Published on 3 years ago By Izlain
1
2
Next

Guilds and Clans

  • Ascension (GRIP) My WoW guild website… website is gone, guild is still there! (www.aguild.net) 0
  • Forward Line of Own Troops My FPS online clan 0
  • Mongbat (GRIP) WAR Guild 0
  • The Grove Message Boards – First EQ guild on Testserver cue nostalgia! 0

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
  • 2K Games
  • Activision
  • ALpha
  • Amazon
  • Anthem
  • Apple
  • Arenanet
  • Art
  • ArtCraft Entertainment
  • Battlefield
  • Beta
  • Bethesda
  • Bioware
  • Black Sand Studios
  • Blaugust
  • Blizzard
  • BlogNation
  • Broadsword (DAOC)
  • Bteam
  • Bungie
  • Carbine
  • Casual
  • CCP
  • CD Projekt
  • City State Entertainment
  • clash royale
  • Cloud Imperium Games
  • Codename Entertainment
  • Combat Testing
  • Comics
  • Commodore
  • Community
  • Creaky Corpse LTD
  • Critical Role
  • Cruising
  • Cyanide
  • Cyberpunk 2077
  • D&D
  • Dauntless
  • Daybreak (SOE)
  • DDO
  • Destiny
  • Developers
  • DICE
  • Digital Extremes
  • Disney
  • Draft Necromancy
  • Dungeons and Dragons
  • EA
  • Economist
  • Epic Games
  • EQ2
  • Everquest
  • Fallout
  • Fashionably Late
  • Firaxis
  • Fortnite
  • FPS
  • Freaky Friday
  • Funcom
  • Gazillion
  • General
  • Gong Show
  • Google
  • Hardware
  • Harebrained Schemes
  • Hearthstone
  • Heroes of Hammerwatch II
  • Hi-Rez Studios
  • Idle COTFR
  • iHasConsole
  • iHAShealth
  • IHASPC
  • Indy
  • Keen Games
  • Kickstarter
  • Life (and Interwebs)
  • Lore
  • LOTRO
  • Ludeon
  • Ludia
  • Magic The Gathering
  • Marvel
  • Microsoft
  • Minecraft
  • MMO
  • Mobile Games
  • Monte Crisco
  • Movies
  • MSDOS
  • Mythic
  • Naughty Dog
  • ncsoft
  • NetEase
  • NetherRealm
  • news
  • Nexon
  • Nintendo
  • Nodding Wistfully
  • Obsidian
  • P1999
  • pages
  • Paladins
  • Pantheon MMO
  • Personal
  • Politics (sorry!)
  • Project 1999
  • PS4
  • PVP
  • random thoughts
  • REading
  • Red Hook Studios
  • Respawn
  • Riot
  • Rocksteady
  • RogueLike
  • RPG
  • RTS
  • Sandbox
  • Sid Meier
  • Slay The Spire
  • Sony
  • Sports
  • Square Enix
  • Star Wars
  • Steam
  • Strategy
  • Super Heroes
  • SUPERCELL
  • SuperGiant
  • SWKOTORMMORPG
  • TellTale Games
  • The Indie Stone
  • Third Person Shooter
  • THQ
  • Tom CLancy
  • Torchlight
  • Turbine
  • TV
  • Twitter
  • Ubisoft
  • Uncategorized
  • Valve
  • Videos
  • Vindictus
  • Visionary Realms
  • Warriors of Waterdeep
  • WildStar
  • Wizards of the Coast
  • World of Warcraft
  • Year in Review
  • Zombie
©2025 | Built using WordPress and Responsive Blogily theme by Superb
%d